>>New plan will cost me $2500, due to New Hampshires high property tax.<<
I find that hard to believe. Take a look here and let us know if you’re right: http://taxplancalculator.com/calc
So unless there is something else going on with your taxes, your net tax bill will indeed go down significantly. ($4,069 + $875 - $1,804 = $3,140 lower)
I'm SO bad at math, I stopped balancing my checkbook 50 years ago; but, by living within my means, I managed to accumulate a decent bundle. :)
I was hoping the tax bracket "moves"and taking the new standard deductionmight save me. :)