No matter what, the CO and OOD of the Fitz have a lot of ‘splainin to do.
But I still think it’s possible to lie your way into a deliberate collision in the last minute. “Don’t worry, I’m turning to port, I’ll pass behind your stern.”
Then turn hard to starboard, the Fitz never in their wildest dreams believing this could happen.
It goes on and on. Of course, CO, XO and Navigator will have to explain how the OOD and CIC watch officer were properly qualified for their positions, etc. etc.
Fertile grounds for a board of inquiry.
Bottom line though, some poor O-2 / O-3 deck officer is in a world of hurt.