Is oil a renewable resource?
http://www.cfact.org/2012/09/19/is-oil-a-renewable-resource/
Stuff dies and rots. As long as it happens fossil fuels are formed.
The rate that we are producing it is much faster than the rate it is being formed. It must migrate one drop at a time into a trap. If the author’s premise was correct, then currently formed traps would be recharged. That has never been known to occur.