[Tammy8]

The courts have handed illegals our Constitutional Rights on a silver platter so often it is now the law of the land. As to those in another country wanting to come here- if our government sets up a system to deny Muslims or other by group they cannot violate anyone’s rights in doing so or it will be thrown out.

I think what Giuliani is saying is we cannot single out Muslims and have it hold up in court. We can stop all immigration while we sort it out or we can set up rules that all must follow no matter where they are from- background checks are a good thing to use. Many cannot really be vetted because the country they are coming from does not keep proper records. We could exclude those with a blank background as a security risk no matter where they are from. Legally I am sure he is right that we cannot exclude a particular group.

[miss marmelstein]

That’s nuts.

[Political Junkie Too]

It depends on what you mean by "particular group." Are you saying that, for example, we cannot ban anyone from Iran, Syria, or Libya, from entering, those being three particular particular groups? Do we have any sovereignty at all to stop nationals from another country from entering the United States?

-PJ