It also has problems. There is no perfect solution.
were it up to me the meaning of “The judges, both of the supreme and inferior courts, shall hold their offices during good behaviour,” would mean that if a vote of both houses stated that a Justice due to a decision on the court was against the meaning of the Constitution and the president agreed (or was over ridden by 2/3) that member of the court would be removed from office.
No need to impeach, though the effect is similar. Just the peoples representative stating that your decision was bad behavior and your shall not make any more
It would not happen often but it would maybe keep all sides playing fair.
IF a dem congress tried to remove all of the conservatives they would KNOW that if it ever changed the pay back would bw swift and the other way as well.
“It also has problems. There is no perfect solution.”
Agreed. I can’t conceive a perfect solution to any of this either.
By a simple majority, Congress can strip a subject from the jurisdiction of the Court. Which tells you how much the Republicans really care about abortion.