You're right, my total bad. John Allen is with the Reporter. And my take is that Lefty Newsweek was well aware of the logical contradiction built into the story. Probably, the gay mafia within the Vatican or inside some diocese has framed this story to its friends in the media to attack their enemy, Msgr. Anatrella.
The ReporterDistorter has been Newsweek's sole source on matters Catholic for decades.
Thank God - literally - for the Reformation