[pierrem15]

Exactly why could we not pass a law stripping them of such protections when we could withdraw from the whole treaty if we wished?

[Monty22002]

When it comes down to it ‘war treaties’ don’t mean jack. Maybe some niceties when things are mild like 9/11, but if things REALLY hit the fan, all that ‘treaty’ stuff goes out the window. And that goes for all sides.

[DoodleDawg]

Exactly why could we not pass a law stripping them of such protections when we could withdraw from the whole treaty if we wished?

Because we did not write the treaty or define who was covered so we can't arbitrarily change it, though you are correct that we could probably withdraw any time we wished.

[ConfidentConservative]

“Exactly why could we not pass a law stripping them of such protections when we could withdraw from the whole treaty if we wished?”

What Treaty for us when they are coming over the border in mass?
All our libs will want is to hug them, kiss them because the libs are SURE that is all that is needed to change their view.

How well has that worked in Germany, Sweden or England?

Trump is RIGHT we need to get tough and secure our borders.