Unfortunately there are a few plausible opinions on why he is not.
There will be a Federal Court case on this one that eventually reaches the USSC.
My prejudice is clear, I believe NBC is born to two US Citizens on US territory, whether Puerto Rico, Guam or a Air Force base on Kwajalein Atoll. And all the 50 states.
I'm old fashioned that way.
But, I don't believe that it's a legal opinion that will prevail.
“There will be a Federal Court case on this one that eventually reaches the USSC. ....”
Will this be the same SCOTUS that gave us abortion, eminent domain, ruled Obamacare as legal, etc.. Count me someone who would be nervous about SCOTUS “judgment.”