Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

How Government Aggravates Airline Delays
Townhall.com ^ | January 7, 2016 | Steve Chapman

Posted on 01/07/2016 9:29:04 AM PST by Kaslin

Governments often act in response to perceived crises, which is not to say they act in ways that are helpful. The point is to be seen as doing something. The danger of a crisis is that it blinds policymakers to the fact that their remedies can cause more harm than they cure.

In the summer of 2007, the supposed emergency unfolded on airport tarmacs, where a small but noticeable number of commercial jets were stuck for hours waiting to depart. The passengers were unable to get to their destinations, but they were also unable to get off the plane. A February ice storm that hit New York stranded some travelers for 10 hours as food ran out and toilets filled up.

Congress might have assumed that in a competitive market, airlines that subjected their customers to intolerable conditions would be forced to improve or go bankrupt -- as many carriers have done.

The airlines involved in these ordeals apologized and vowed to avoid any repetition. After travelers on one flight endured an eight-hour delay, an American Airlines official said, "This was an extraordinary circumstance. We have learned from it, and frankly we don't expect it to ever happen again."

Even in 2007, the worst year, these events were exceptionally rare. They soon got even scarcer. By 2009, the number of tarmac delays lasting three hours or more had declined by 64 percent.

But that improvement did not satisfy the Obama administration. In 2009, it decreed that if passengers on a plane are stuck on the tarmac for more than three hours, the carrier is liable for a fine of $27,500 per passenger -- which on a typical flight could exceed $5 million.

"Airline passengers have rights," proclaimed Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, "and these new rules will require airlines to live up to their obligation to treat their customers fairly."

But for almost every government action, there is an unwanted outcome. Threatening ruinous penalties worked beautifully in keeping passengers from being held for lengthy periods on the runway. Three-hour tarmac delays have gone the way of hot meals in coach, dropping by 99.6 percent. But that doesn't mean travelers are no longer being subjected to maddening snafus.

Scholars Vikrant Vaze of Dartmouth and Chiwei Yan, Allison Vanderboll and Cynthia Barnhart of MIT found a less congenial effect: a sharp increase in flight cancellations. A carrier faced with the prospect of keeping a plane full of anxious passengers on board too long, incurring a heavy fine, often ends up scrubbing the flight.

In that case, passengers who might have waited four hours to take off may find themselves waiting even longer to catch another flight. They may be stuck at airports far from home, sitting or sleeping on the floor. They may miss connecting flights.

They may also incur expenses for food, lodging and other needs. Some of them won't ever get where they planned to go, because the delay renders the trip pointless.

Overall, the study found, "each passenger-minute of tarmac time saving is achieved at the cost of approximately three passenger-minutes in total passenger delays. This is due primarily to increases in flight cancellations." The authors' conclusion confirms the finding of a 2011 report from the federal Government Accountability Office.

This consequence was unintended but not unforeseeable. In fact, it was foreseen. In 2007, when the idea gained currency, a spokesman for the Air Transport Association of America warned: "You have to keep in mind, if there is legislation that imposes inflexible standards on a carrier's operations, that easily could have the unintended effect of inconveniencing customers more in some situations. It's not always the easy or the right choice to simply say, 'After a period of time, you have to go back to the gate.'"

The prediction was dismissed as special interest whining. No one was inclined to listen to people whose livelihood depends on accommodating the demands of the flying public. The assumption that government policymakers know better is one that stubbornly endures in Washington, despite being refuted over and over.

The reason this attempt to force change on airlines and passengers didn't work out well is the same reason so many government ventures founder. No one bothered to ask the crucial question for any new policy: "And then what?"


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Editorial; Government
KEYWORDS: airlines

1 posted on 01/07/2016 9:29:04 AM PST by Kaslin
[ Post Reply]

To: Kaslin

“The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the Government, and I’m here to help. “

- Ronald Reagan, August 12, 1986


2 posted on 01/07/2016 9:32:44 AM PST by thackney (life is fragile, handle with prayer)
[ Post Reply]

To: Kaslin

Arrivals and departures on time is all about avail of boarding gates and people to staff them.


3 posted on 01/07/2016 9:37:22 AM PST by blackdog (There is no such thing as healing, only a balance between destructive and constructive forces.)
[ Post Reply]

To: Kaslin

I think it would be well for us to find out just why any flight would be held on the ground for anything like an hour, let alone three or more hours. These kinds of delays are often as long as the flights would take to complete. My guess is that weather may cause some of the delays, but more often than not, the problem is likely with our antequated Air Traffic Control “System.” The FAA has been dragging it’s feet for years delaying the implementation of an ATC system based on GPS rather than the Airways “system” that’s been in place since WWII. The story is that the FAA doesn’t ever do anything until people die. Some of the current ATC equipment is so old that they have to keep a vacuum tube mfr. in business so they have a supply of replacement parts.


4 posted on 01/07/2016 9:41:04 AM PST by vette6387
[ Post Reply]

To: Kaslin

The general rule for any economic decision, is that it is best made at the point of impact (ergo, the airline, the aircraft, the pilot, the gate controller, etc).

The general rule for any statist making general rules, is that it is best made at the point of highest power (ergo, furthest from point of impact, by the statist, the 5-year plan, the politburo, a czar, etc).

In the former case, economic dislocations are at a minimum, in the latter, at a maximum.


5 posted on 01/07/2016 9:44:03 AM PST by C210N (Supporting the Constitutional Conservative in the race. Constitutional Conservative Cruz.)
[ Post Reply]

To: Kaslin

Obama F’s it up again


6 posted on 01/07/2016 10:13:10 AM PST by mfish13 (Elections have Consequences.)
[ Post Reply]

To: mfish13

That’s nothing new.


7 posted on 01/07/2016 10:17:47 AM PST by Kaslin (He needed the ignorant to reelect him, and he got them. Now we all have to pay the consequenses)
[ Post Reply]

To: Kaslin

Yes, sorry for stating the obvious.


8 posted on 01/07/2016 10:29:47 AM PST by mfish13 (Elections have Consequences.)
[ Post Reply]

To: vette6387
Some of the current ATC equipment is so old that they have to keep a vacuum tube mfr. in business so they have a supply of replacement parts.

My summary reaction : That is said as if it were a bad thing.

Critics and anonymous commenters live in a private bubble, isolated from everything else in the Universe, blissfully oblivious that, as someone once said, everything is connected in various ways to everything else in the universe.

What is the connection among the following :?

Murdering Mass Muslims?
911?
Airport Security?
Incompetent central government?
Political correctness?
"Playing Nice" with terrorist groups and religions of peace?
Constant Rapid technological advancements?
Criminal "executive order agreements" with nuclear prolifirators?
Possible ways to apply weapons of mass destruction?

EMP?

It is common knowledge among normal informed adults (excepting, by definition, TI* "progressives" and gibsmedat Barack Hussein supporters) That EMP is the most effective means of paralyzing a nation, and of setting back cultural existence 100 years, yet known to man as a weapon.

It is also well understood, for 60+ years now (for adults with a vague familiarity with science and math beyond elementary school*) that most, if not ALL electronic devices that exist, controlling every facet of life existence from the ability to drive (and commute) to the internet to GPS to cell phones to water supplies including dams to communications of all kinds to treatment plants to medical devices to "smart" electronics of every variety, ad infinitum, are instantly disabled or destroyed by EMP.

Contrary to the implicit absurd statement that vacuum tube equipment in the traffic control system are bad bad and that it has not been replaced is a national disgrace and a critical emergency, the reverse is true; it may have been a blessing in disguise in a dysfunctional political system.

Simple "Old technology" updated by the advances in technology, it the simplest most economical means to eliminate that particular universal fatal threat!

As an example with airline travel, looking at the economy of fixing the potentially fatal flaw problem, is it cheaper to "harden" every existing airplane, train or ship or simply to return to vacuum tubes in emergency backup devices both in aircraft and Air traffic control locations?

9 posted on 01/07/2016 10:53:28 AM PST by publius911 (IMPEACH HIM NOW! evil ignorant stupid or crazy-doesn't matter!<p>)
[ Post Reply]

To: C210N

Well said. Another reason the bureaucrat pushes all decisions up the ladder is plausable deniability. No bureaucrat EVER wants to be held accountable for a concrete decision.


10 posted on 01/07/2016 10:55:39 AM PST by IronJack
[ Post Reply]

To: publius911

Are you sure you don’t need to check yourself in to the hospital? I’m worried that your tinfoil hat is on too tight!


11 posted on 01/07/2016 11:09:50 AM PST by vette6387
[ Post Reply]

To: vette6387
Are you sure you don't need to check yourself in to the hospital? I'm worried that your tinfoil hat is on too tight!

It was so nice of you to worry about me.

To answer your question, I do that regularly, and I've been cleared every time.

Aside from that, ignorance is bliss. Your non-responsive response proves my point; just google EMP and get back to me, assuming you are capable of understanding the issue..

Assuming that you are a sentient being, how about refuting any of my statements? unless, of course you are among the science and math totally ignorant. In which case, it was nice chatting with you.

Once.

12 posted on 01/07/2016 11:30:13 AM PST by publius911 (IMPEACH HIM NOW! evil ignorant stupid or crazy-doesn't matter!<p>)
[ Post Reply]

To: vette6387

>>I think it would be well for us to find out just why any flight would be held on the ground for anything like an hour, let alone three or more hours. <<

It starts with bad weather at the destination airport. When you have an airport that normally lands 20 aircraft per hour and all of a sudden can’t land one. All the aircraft that are already enroute to the airport that is shutdown need some where to land. All the aircraft which have not yet completed take off must remain on the ground as they will only exaggerate the problem.

The longer the destination airport remains shutdown the bigger the problem gets. Remember too that there is more aircraft than there is gate spaces.


13 posted on 01/07/2016 11:32:43 AM PST by B4Ranch
[ Post Reply]

To: B4Ranch

Well, that may the case at some airports, but as a pilot I do know that here in the SF Bay area all our airports are CATIIIB which means the pilots don’t even have to touch the controls until the plane rolls out. As for the lack of gate space, that’s an alrline problem. You can’t fly more trips than you can load and unload, but they do it anyway and think nothing of pi$$ing off their customers. So, in a perverse way, the government penalties do help to cut down flights to the point where the flights they do have, get to go on time. But the lack of a state-of-the-art ATC system is also a major contributor. Flying in a congo line on airways basically limits the flow of traffic. The current system is high button shoes technology, which shows once again that the government is a failure.


14 posted on 01/07/2016 1:10:09 PM PST by vette6387
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson