Posted on 01/04/2016 5:15:27 AM PST by sukhoi-30mki
Saab is trying to find customers in Asia. A recent report indicated that the Swedish defense firm is trying to find partners in Asia for the Sea Gripen, a carrier-launched version of its much-lauded, relatively inexpensive Generation 4.5 fighter.
The problem is that the market for fighter aircraft is tight, because there are several good competitors and not enough aircraft carriers to go around. Thus have culminated a pair of long-standing trends in naval and aviation acquisition: good aircraft are chasing decks that simply donât exist. To see how we got here, itâs useful to trace a bit of the intertwined histories of carriers and airwings.
The first generation of small carriers were mostly Colossus and Majestic class light carriers, sold by the United Kingdom in the wake of World War II. These ships served a variety of navies around the world, including several in Asia. Their air wings varied a lot over time, from piston-engined fighters near the end of World War II to helicopters and small jets in the 1970s. Embarked aircraft included the A-4 Skyhawk, F9F Panther, Super Etendard, and Hawker Sea Hawk, among others. These ships (and most of the aircraft) began to leave service in the 1970s and 1980s.
The next generation of purpose-built ships includes such vessels as the Thai Chakri Naruebet, as well as a few small European carriers. These ships often carried variants of the AV-8 Harrier, along with a collection of helicopters. The Harrier is a notoriously difficult aircraft, however, especially for navies that considered aviation a luxury, rather than a necessity. For this kind of carrier the F-35B would fit the bill nicely, except for the expense. Most of these ships are still in service, although the Harrier is on its last legs.
The current generation has witnessed a high-low split. Cost-conscious navies have determined that larger, purpose-built carriers donât offer sufficient bang-for-the-buck, especially with regard to humanitarian assistance/disaster relief (HADR). Helicopters, drones, and (for the fortunate) the V-22 Osprey would seem likely to dominate this generation, although there is still some prospect that the F-35B might fly off some of these carriers.
China, India, Russia, France, the U.K., and the United States, on the other hand, have decided to concentrate on large carriers designed to accommodate conventional fixed wing aircraft. This would seem to present a viable market, but four of the six have decided on domestically produced fighters, and the British have settled on the F-35B.
This means that, for all intents and purposes, India and Brazil are the beginning and end of the market that is being pursued by Mikoyan (MiG-29K), Sukhoi (Su-33), Saab (Sea Gripen), Boeing (F/A-18), Lockheed Martin (F-35B, F-35C), Shenyang (J-15, J-31), HAL (Tejas), and Dassault (Rafale), and even Brazil needs to sort through its long-term carrier plans before it buys a new fighter.
Unless thereâs some kind of significant change in shipbuilding policies, most of these companies are going to be shut out of anything but their domestic markets. At the same time, there remains a potential niche that could be exploited by a firm that could design a VSTOL aircraft capable of operating from small carriers and amphibs, and that could sell for cheaper than the F-35B. Unfortunately, thatâs a tall order.
I don’t know much about this topic, but I would think, unless your aircraft are look first shoot first, buying an expensive plane for your aging fleet of carriers doesn’t make much sense.
India went with the Mig-29K< and they will compliment that with their own naval LCA, Tejas.
Brazil is going toward the Gripen and has already inked the deal for their Air Force which includes the Sea Gripen development.
Russia is converting over to the Mig-29K.
China has its own J-15 and will undoubtedly take care f its own future development plans.
France uses its own jets, notably the very capable Rafale M.
The US is going to be flying the F/A-18E/F, F-35C, and UCAV off the large carriers. The LHA and LHDs are going to use the F-35B. The jump-jet carriers of allies are all similar to the LAH, but most of them have a ski-jump.
This means that the UK is going to use the F-35B. Italy will use the F-35B. Spain will ultimately use the F-35B. Both Korea and Japan are going towards such features for future carrier builds/improvements to the Dokdo and Izumo classes...and they will use the F-35B.
Thailand still has its single small carrier, but they do not have the money to do much with it and I cannot remember the last time their few Harriers flew off of it. If they do upgrade...the only option is the F-35B but at this point that seems unlikely.
Australia has opted to this point on know fixed wing aircraft for their Canberras...even though they retain the ski-jump.
As far as potential carriers go...that’s it. The Mig-29K is going to have a small market with Russia and INdia, and India is going to end up with three carriers, so more will be built.
The Sea Gripen’s only potential country at this point seems to be Brazil and I believe it will be built...but probably no more than 40 of the,
I agree and I know less than u I’m sure.
But, it seems 101 that if I’m flying along and can kill you say 100 miles away but you have to get within say 50 miles of me before you can kill me that it is just then and there game over and nothing else matters!
The Sea Gripen may have another opening in the Indian Navy. The Tejas Mk2 variant, which was primarily meant for the Indian Navy, may not see the light of day since the Indian Air Force has for (at least the time being) pulled out of the project.
If the Indian Air Force is purchasing the French Rafale, wouldn’t it make more sense for the Indian Navy to get the Rafale-M?
It makes more sense, but the costs would be a factor against the Rafale-M.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.