John Jay in corresponding with George Washington on the subject, stated that it was particularly appropriate to limit the Presidency to natural born citizens because the President was the Commander-in-Chief of America's military and the natural born citizen requirement therefor would act as a check on our military from ever falling into the hands of a foreigner.
This little girl is not a foreigner. She’s American. She has never known any other language beside English.
Even so, I hardly think the reasoning behind either Jay’s or Story’s opinion holds water.