[dennisw]

I could care less what this lawyer’s case is. I want someone (lawyer) who can make the case that no offspring of illegal immigrants automatically become citizens. Then I want a President and a Congress who can carry it out.

No other nations allows this birthright scam so who would I want half a loaf that this author argues? You know what is fair and so do I. So get the laws changed to go along with our thinking. I don’t care what a President Trump does to stop birthright citizenship. Just so long as it gets done. THE CONSTITUTION IS NOT A SUICIDE PACT

[nathanbedford]

The reason we pay attention to court decisions is because they affect the way we govern ourselves. The reason we pay attention to Law Review articles is because they produce the most respected analyses of court decisions.

This lawyer, writing a Law Review article concerning a court decision concludes that neither the president nor the Congress can deprive babies of domiciled illegal aliens the right to citizenship but they may constitutionally do so for "tourism babies."

The article may be wrong, but at least we are dealing with the issue on the merits and not trumpeting bombast.