A cop can only order you to put out a cig in your own home if your under detainment or arrest or your house is being searched (under consent or warrant) and the officer feels the cig can be used as a weapon or to alter/destroy evidence. If he just comes to the door to ask you about recent neighborhood crime then he can ask you to put it out, but can’t order you to since you are not detained or arrested. This lady WAS detained. That is the difference.
Same goes with a car. He could order her out of the car and if she brought the ciggy with her then he can tell her what to do with it on the grounds the scary girl might burn him with the ciggy, however being that smoking while in a car is not against the law he can ask but ordering and her saying no is the same as saying no to a search.
She wasn’t detained. Are you freaking joking me? He had already issued the warning. She was in her vehicle when he ordered the cigarette be put out.
He detained her AFTER she refused his order. Now you are saying he detained her BEFORE she refused his order.
You are a joke!