The author elevates science to an ideology or as some called scientificism. The relationship of science and history is much more complicated and not so Whiggish as Mr. Shermer portrays it. How it is the most scientifically advanced society in the world slaughtered 6 MM Jews? How is it that when Darwin's theory of evolution came out it was used to justify every political-economic theory at the time from extreme Laissez Faire to Socialism/Communism to Racism. How is it that a gov't supposedly founded on the scientific principles of history derived from Marx slaughtered tens of millions? Did you know the Victorian era Workhouses decried by social reformers was the so called product of a "scientific" look by Benthamites/Utilitarians who applied Newtonian like calculations at the issue of social welfare programs. I can go on with other example like eugenics. Science is a tool and just like any tools has been used for both good and ill.
1 posted on
04/06/2015 9:37:19 AM PDT by
C19fan
To: C19fan
Oops Scientificism should be Scientism.
2 posted on
04/06/2015 9:46:46 AM PDT by
C19fan
To: C19fan
Michael Shermer is the Publisher of Skeptic magazine, a monthly columnist for Scientific American, and a presidential fellow at Chapman University. His new book, on which this article is based, is The Moral Arc: How Science and Reason Lead Humanity Toward Truth, Justice, and Freedom (Henry Holt, 2015). Actually, Michael Shermer is a true believer in the Church of Global Warming, and nothing like a "skeptic".
He seems to mistakenly believe that there has been no pause in "global warming", although even so-called "climate scientists" have been forced to admit that it exists and that it was not predicted by their global circulation models.
How unscientific of Michael Shermer to disregard what even the IPCC has acknowledged. His attacks on Cruz are misplaced - perhaps he should look in the mirror and cure his own unscientific behavior and politicization of the facts before trying to cure others' supposed faults.
3 posted on
04/06/2015 9:51:10 AM PDT by
Zeppo
("Happy Pony is on - and I'm NOT missing Happy Pony")
To: C19fan
Michael Shermer spews more "Climate Change" Chicken Little garbage at Politboro, once again proving that in the heads of all Liberals:
4 posted on
04/06/2015 9:54:34 AM PDT by
Col Freeper
(FR: A smorgasbord of Conservative Mindfood - dig in and enjoy it!)
To: C19fan
1970 Colder Winters Held Dawn of New Ice Age Scientists See Ice Age In the Future (The Washington Post, January 11, 1970)
1970 Is Mankind Manufacturing a New Ice Age for Itself? (L.A. Times, January 15, 1970)
1970 New Ice Age May Descend On Man (Sumter Daily Item, January 26, 1970)
1970 Pollution Prospect A Chilling One (Owosso Argus-Press, January 26, 1970)
1970 Pollutions 2-way Freeze On Society (Middlesboro Daily News, January 28, 1970)
1970 Cold Facts About Pollution (The Southeast Missourian, January 29, 1970)
1970 Pollution Could Cause Ice Age, Agency Reports (St. Petersburg Times, March 4, 1970)
1970 Pollution Called Ice Age Threat (St. Petersburg Times, June 26, 1970)
1970 Dirt Will .Bring New Ice Age (The Sydney Morning Herald, October 19, 1970)
1971 Ice Age Refugee Dies Underground (The Montreal Gazette, Febuary 17, 1971)
1971 U.S. Scientist Sees New Ice Age Coming (The Washington Post, July 9, 1971)
1971 Ice Age Around the Corner (Chicago Tribune, July 10, 1971)
1971 New Ice Age Coming Its Already Getting Colder (L.A. Times, October 24, 1971)
1971 Another Ice Age? Pollution Blocking Sunlight (The Day, November 1, 1971)
1971 Air Pollution Could Bring An Ice Age (Harlan Daily Enterprise, November 4, 1971)
1972 Air pollution may cause ice age (Free-Lance Star, February 3, 1972)
1972 Scientist Says New ice Age Coming (The Ledger, February 13, 1972)
1972 Scientist predicts new ice age (Free-Lance Star, September 11, 1972)
1972 British expert on Climate Change says Says New Ice Age Creeping Over Northern Hemisphere (Lewiston Evening Journal, September 11, 1972)
1972 Climate Seen Cooling For Return Of Ice Age (Portsmouth Times, ?September 11, 1972?)
1972 New Ice Age Slipping Over North (Press-Courier, September 11, 1972)
1972 Ice Age Begins A New Assault In North (The Age, September 12, 1972)
1972 Weather To Get Colder (Montreal Gazette, ?September 12, 1972?)
1972 British climate expert predicts new Ice Age (The Christian Science Monitor, September 23, 1972)
1972 Scientist Sees Chilling Signs of New Ice Age (L.A. Times, September 24, 1972)
1972 Science: Another Ice Age? (Time Magazine, November 13, 1972)
1973 The Ice Age Cometh (The Saturday Review, March 24, 1973)
1973 Weather-watchers think another ice age may be on the way (The Christian Science Monitor, December 11, 1973)
1974 New evidence indicates ice age here (Eugene Register-Guard, May 29, 1974)
1974 Another Ice Age? (Time Magazine, June 24, 1974)
1974 2 Scientists Think Little Ice Age Near (The Hartford Courant, August 11, 1974)
1974 Ice Age, worse food crisis seen (The Chicago Tribune, October 30, 1974)
1974 Believes Pollution Could Bring On Ice Age (Ludington Daily News, December 4, 1974)
1974 Pollution Could Spur Ice Age, Nasa Says (Beaver Country Times, ?December 4, 1974?)
1974 Air Pollution May Trigger Ice Age, Scientists Feel (The Telegraph, ?December 5, 1974?)
1974 More Air Pollution Could Trigger Ice Age Disaster (Daily Sentinel ?December 5, 1974?)
1974 Scientists Fear Smog Could Cause Ice Age (Milwaukee Journal, December 5, 1974)
1975 Climate Changes Called Ominous (The New York Times, January 19, 1975)
1975 Climate Change: Chilling Possibilities (Science News, March 1, 1975)
1975 B-r-r-r-r: New Ice Age on way soon? (The Chicago Tribune, March 2, 1975)
1975 Cooling Trends Arouse Fear That New Ice Age Coming (Eugene Register-Guard, ?March 2, 1975?)
1975 Is Another Ice Age Due? Arctic Ice Expands In Last Decade (Youngstown Vindicator ?March 2, 1975?)
1975 Is Earth Headed For Another Ice Age? (Reading Eagle, March 2, 1975)
1975 New Ice Age Dawning? Significant Shift In Climate Seen (Times Daily, ?March 2, 1975?)
1975 Theres Troublesome Weather Ahead (Tri City Herald, ?March 2, 1975?)
1975 Is Earth Doomed To Live Through Another Ice Age? (The Robesonian, ?March 3, 1975?)
1975 The Ice Age cometh: the system that controls our climate (The Chicago Tribune, April 13, 1975)
1975 The Cooling World (Newsweek, April 28, 1975)
1975 Scientists Ask Why World Climate Is Changing; Major Cooling May Be Ahead (PDF) (The New York Times, May 21, 1975)
1975 In the Grip of a New Ice Age? (International Wildlife, July-August, 1975)
1975 Oil Spill Could Cause New Ice Age (Milwaukee Journal, December 11, 1975)
1976 The Cooling: Has the Next Ice Age Already Begun? [Book] (Lowell Ponte, 1976)
1977 Blizzard What Happens if it Doesnt Stop? [Book] (George Stone, 1977)
1977 The Weather Conspiracy: The Coming of the New Ice Age [Book] (The Impact Team, 1977)
1976 Worrisome CIA Report; Even U.S. Farms May be Hit by Cooling Trend (U.S. News & World Report, May 31, 1976)
1977 The Big Freeze (Time Magazine, January 31, 1977)
1977 We Will Freeze in the Dark (Capital Cities Communications Documentary, Host: Nancy Dickerson, April 12, 1977)
1978 The New Ice Age [Book] (Henry Gilfond, 1978)
1978 Little Ice Age: Severe winters and cool summers ahead (Calgary Herald, January 10, 1978)
1978 Winters Will Get Colder, were Entering Little Ice Age (Ellensburg Daily Record, January 10, 1978)
1978 Geologist Says Winters Getting Colder (Middlesboro Daily News, January 16, 1978)
1978 Its Going To Get Colder (Boca Raton News, ?January 17, 1978?)
1978 Believe new ice age is coming (The Bryan Times, March 31, 1978)
1978 The Coming Ice Age (In Search Of TV Show, Season 2, Episode 23, Host: Leonard Nimoy, May 1978)
1978 An Ice Age Is Coming Weather Expert Fears (Milwaukee Sentinel, November 17, 1978)
1979 A Choice of Catastrophes The Disasters That Threaten Our World [Book] (Isaac Asimov, 1979)
1979 Get Ready to Freeze (Spokane Daily Chronicle, October 12, 1979)
5 posted on
04/06/2015 9:55:50 AM PDT by
Heartlander
(Prediction: Increasingly, logic will be seen as a covert form of theism. - Denyse OÂ’Leary)
To: C19fan
“When you look at all the data published by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (not just the cherry-picked data that fits neatly into a political ideology), the long-term increase in global temperatures unmistakable.”
The author cherry picks, then complains about cherry picking by others. Why is a starting point at the year 1980 sacrosanct and “long term”, whereas another starting point would be “cherry picked” and “short term”? What are the uncertainties/inaccuracies in the NOAA data, and how do they compare to the “trend”? Given a trend, how do they know that it will continue and it’s manmade? Given that it will continue, and is manmade, that it’s undesirable? Given that it’s undesirable, that it can and should be improved by changes in our behavior?
If he were honest, he would acknowledge that those who disagree are skeptics, not “deniers”. He and his ilk are making assertions; they are the ones that have the burden of proof. Instead they engage in ad hominem arguments. Is that the best they can do?
To: C19fan
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_engineering
It’s big business.
Just for starters, destroying the CA agriculture industry was a prerequisite to large-scale importation of ag products from third-world countries.
This is the scale globalists think on.
Every idea that gets touted to “solve” a “problem” is yet another multi-billion dollar boondoggle.
7 posted on
04/06/2015 10:01:29 AM PDT by
PieterCasparzen
(Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.)
To: C19fan
Science explains God's work.It’s not complicated (understanding that fact,that is).
8 posted on
04/06/2015 10:25:20 AM PDT by
Gay State Conservative
(Obama;A Low Grade Intellect With Even Lower Morals)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson