I would think it would be "I Brake for ShooFly Pie", but then, I don't speak Amish...
I would think it would be “I Brake for ShooFly Pie”, but then, I don’t speak Amish..”
Actually it could be either. “I Break...” because it is something you eat and you normally take a break from work when you eat. “I Brake..” because you see a sign ahead that tells you about a restaurant that is serving ShooFly Pie and so you want to stop.
If you want to be Amish, you do break for ShooFly Pie, however.