[Vigilanteman]

My top 10:

1. Washington
   
2. Jefferson
   
3. Reagan
   
4. Lincoln
   
5. Monroe
   
6. Coolidge
   
7. Cleveland
   
8. Madison
   
9. Teddy
   
10. Fillmore

The first five were definitely in the "great" category. The second five were maybe "damn good." Andy Jackson would've made my list if he'd had the ability to distinguish between hostile Native Americans and those who weren't. But he didn't. What he allowed to happen to the Cherokee, in particular, was utterly shameful.

[Buckeye McFrog]

Have to agree based on your list that W would not be considered “great”.

[Scoutmaster]

My Millard Fillmore memorabilia collection salutes you.