if I had to pick between Gutfeld and O’Reily I’d still pick O’Reily. Gutfeld is just too goofy and is never serious. RedEye is just a Fox version of Colbert Report or the Daily Show and I just don’t find those types of shows funny or entertaining. It seems those shows are geared for teens/early 20somethings with the sophomoric/immature humor.
Hell, Gutfeld doesn't even take himself seriously half the time. He'd probably be fun to have a beer with.
O'Reilly, on the other hand, is a self-consumed no-it-all who must be a pain in the butt to be around for any length of time.
If I was picking a next door neighbor from those two, it would be Gutfeld hands down.