1. HFT doesnt prey on small mom-and-pop investors. In his first two TV appearances, Lewis stuck to a simple pitch: Speed traders have rigged the stock market, and the biggest losers are average, middle-class retail investorsexactly the kind of people who watch 60 Minutes and the Today show. Its the guy sitting at his ETrade (ETFC) account, Lewis told Matt Lauer. The way Lewis sees it, speed traders prey on retail investors by trading against people who dont know the market.
The idea that retail investors are losing out to sophisticated speed traders is an old claim in the debate over HFT, and its pretty much been discredited. Speed traders arent competing against the ETrade guy, theyre competing with each other to fill the ETrade guys order. While Lewis does an admirable job in the book of burrowing into the ridiculously complicated system of how orders get routed, he misses badly by making this assumption.
He specifically stated on Jon Stewart’s show last night that HFT doesn’t compete against the guy with the etrade account.