Posted on 02/10/2014 9:49:13 AM PST by Kaslin
Coke’s Super Bowl ad, featuring a montage of America the Beautiful in eight languages amidst scenes of beautiful people and landscapes wins this year’s controversy award. At one level, it’s just a company selling “sugar water,” in Steve Jobs’s famous phrase. But, of course, there’s more to it. Coke spent untold millions to produce a message touching social, cultural, and political nerves to make us notice and talk about it.Coke succeeded. The ad is beautiful, manipulative, disingenuous, and subversive.
Critics have struggled to express what troubles them, some thoughtfully and some in blunderbuss fashion. It’s elusive because the piece is beautiful and humanly warm. Ultimately, criticism of the ad is not about discomfort with diversity. It’s about the limits of diversity in core concepts and sinews that should unite our nation. To fully secure the peace and freedom that enable and animate our human diversity, there has to be a shared governing creed. The ad subtly undermines the idea of any core cultural commonality.
First, let’s get a grip. It’s just a pretty commercial. It’s not a candidate’s platform or a movement’s manifesto. On an importance scale of 1-to-10, this is a 2. The misguided expressions of outrage and calls to boycott Coke played right into the marketing department’s fondest hopes. But smug denunciations of critics and charges of racism and xenophobia weren’t triumphs of intellectual honesty, either.
Embedded in the ad was something unsettling and provocative. It’s not that the ad praised diversity of people and languages in America. It’s not because lots of Americans like to “demonize people who don’t look like the way they’d like them to look like or came from some other place,” Colin Powell’s clumsy recent phrase from another context. America is full of human diversity that Americans rightly celebrate. Coke could have rendered virtually any other song in the same way and no one would have raised an eyebrow.
No, the reaction is not to diversity. The ad is noteworthy and controversial only because it transformed a patriotic song—a sentimental second national anthem for many—to make its multicultural, multi-lingual point.
Still what’s the problem? It is this: the ad is sophisticated and manipulative in service of a fiction. It depicts a vision that doesn’t exist in reality and that its proponents don’t really believe in. It subtly takes sides in a debate about the meaning of America and Americanism. It does these things framed in a way that exalts the left wing view and scores cheap points against traditional understanding of American exceptionalism and against some of its sputtering, not fully artful articulators.
In the simplest terms, the multi-cultural American patriotism depicted in the ad not only doesn’t exist, it’s an oxymoron. There is growing tension between the historic ideas of assimilation on the one hand and preserving a separateness of national and ethnic heritage on the other. The forces arguing for deeper, more divided cultural diversity are not typically flag-waving translators of America the Beautiful into native tongues . They’re not generally the people who revere and sing about pilgrims’ stern impassioned stress, thoroughfares of freedom, and America’s liberating strife. The image is a sugary, beautiful lie.
Subcultures that self-segregate, observe separate national or ethnic traditions, and preserve a different mother tongue, aren’t known for celebrating anything uniquely American.Communities that observe Ramadan, celebrate Cinco de Mayo, or speak of Reconquista, absolutely are part of a beautiful American tapestry. But they aren’t bursting into patriotic American songs. People who were uncomfortable with the ad knew they were being sold a fantasy.
More, the fantasy is at odds with what multi-culturalists value and promote. America the Beautiful, especially in the latter verses, celebrates our nation’s exceptionalism. Multi-culturalists celebrate the universality of humanity and equality of all cultures. Multi-culturalists focus more on the lines from Liberty’s inscription about poor huddled masses than they do on the meaning of “yearning to breathe free.”
What is “free” about America? What about America through the ages has called to striving, seeking people? Is it anything multi-culturalists will describe and defend?It is a life built on freedom, on opportunity, rooted in limited government, and the human chance to succeed or fail. It’s the difference that Ronald Reagan called the “last best hope of man on earth.” Consider a bit more from that famous speech:
“If we lose freedom here, there is no place to escape to. This is the last stand on Earth. And this idea that government is beholden to the people, […] is still the newest and most unique idea in all the long history of man's relation to man. This is the issue […]. Whether we believe in our capacity for self-government or whether we abandon the American revolution and confess that a little intellectual elite in a far-distant capital can plan our lives for us better than we can plan them ourselves.”
President Obama expresses quite a different understanding of American uniqueness when he observes: “I believe in American exceptionalism, just as I suspect that the Brits believe in British exceptionalism and the Greeks believe in Greek exceptionalism.” Nothing special to see here. Move along.
Some viewers of the Coke ad sense the song reflects the spirit that Reagan described, but, they’re being poured a glass of syrup more in tune with Obama’s sensibilities. In the battle over political culture, defenders of American exceptionalism cite various critical elements, including the self-evident truths of the Declaration of Independence, the structure and limits in the Constitution, and the unifying cords of a common national language.The ad subtly and appealingly whispers that none of that matters. Anyone’s idea of America is as good as anyone else’s. There is no exceptional American creed; there are just all the beautiful people of the world.
The ad appealed to human brotherhood and national pride, but pride in what? I wonder what Coke would say.
Switch to root beer
I have no doubt that Coke has an agenda that is antithetical to US nationalism because they are a global company. I think the thing that causes the rub is our expectation that they ( and numerous other seemingly US companies) are still chiefly a US citizen. It is our world view that has been led askew. This ad simply highlights our misunderstanding of the CocaCola’s of the world.
I agree. I did not like more of this goopy, cloying, cutsie-pie multiKulturalism. What ever happened to Americanism? Too much “diverse” immigration is killing it. Of cousre we have many immigrants who really get what America is about.
But for 80% of immigrants America is just an economic zone where they can live better than at home. An economic zone without enforceable borders. Their attitude is >>How dare you enforce border entry and controls!!! This is racist!!
72% of the United States is white.
were 72% of the actors white? no? then i guess they don’t want their business
I don’t have a problem with Coke posting an add using foreign languages as long as they do it in the home country of the language they are using.
That said, This is America. We speak American. Everyone in our ciuntry needs to learn American or go home
This is just the 21st century version of the huggy-wuggy I’d “I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing” ads Coke did in the ‘60s.
The last touchy-feely ad they got right was the Mean Joe Greene ad in the 70s.
I prefer Diet A&W root beer which is among the Dr. Pepper products. I also enjoy Diet Mug root beer but that is unfortunately a Pepsi product.
No more Coca Cola products in this house, ever! Instead of Coke and Sprite it will be the Dr. Pepper/Snapple Group’s (Plano, TX) RC Cola and 7-Up.
As soon as I see little rug rats on my TV, singing God knows what in their gibberish - I commpletely tune out.
Yes, but there *are* people who immigrate here -- or are elsewhere but dream of immigrating here -- because of the kind of liberty and opportunity that makes the USA special. People who really see this country as a beacon. And those are the people I deem to be depicted in the ad. It's true that the America-hating types (illegal alien welfare leeches, Sharia-law fans, etc.,) wouldn't be singing that song in any tongue... which is how we know it's not about them.
Coke pretending to fight for all languages when it surrenders America... how quaint.
Pedophiles pushing children as shields speaking once ghetto ebonic pride is now the rule.
No.
It ....... ISN'T ..... a ....... commercial.
It's a very slickly produced piece of propaganda, and not just propaganda for the purpose of selling a physical product for money.
More to the point:
It's NEVER just entertainment, or just music, or just a movie, or just an ad.
The propagandists WANT you to dismiss their product as mere advertising or mere entertainment. They WANT you to unconsciously wallow in their ideas and ideology ... they WANT you to turn your mind off. Only then can they warp your mind.
Maybe Coke has a problem with the very exact translation of the Bible KJV.
How the world sees us.
"America the Beautiful" in a dozen different forms of noticeably accented English reinforces American cultural unity.
Coca-Cola deliberately, willfully, with malice aforethought spent millions of dollars to undermine American cultural unity under the guise of selling an American product to Americans.
Indeed. This is pimping much like a ponzy scheme. There is much more to the Drink in this, but corporate stakes and investors are also attracted. Coke is a brand, the drink is only an icon.
Basically lobbyists in DC represent corporations and foreign nations. The State base has no respect.
Coke, like most corporations, will invoke everything but the Bible.
The American English’s beauty is of having integrated Cezh words like Dollar , Greek words like OK etc... like no other language nation has done before.
Coke has invented nothing and errs.
I indeed smell some gay agenda in this... this commericial is deceitful and not coming out the closet.
Well said.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.