The problem is we are talking about Muslims and Islam. Islam is an imperialist and supremacist ideology. This deference reinforces their belief that they are superior to all others.
You would deby Muslims the deference you believe is due to Christians and Jews?
I don't see quite how you can bring that off, under the Constitution.
On the other hand, Islam's "imperialist and supremacist ideology" is antithetical to the Constitution. Suppression of women, honor killings, disrespect of other religions, etc. should be prosecuted accordingly -- without any deference whatsoever.