It's not "us"
It's the BLatting OG!
(He gets all riled up when folks pimp for hits.)
I read your links... it doesn’t say what you say it says. It does state a strong preference not to excerpt. The name calling, confrontational enforcement and general jerk behavior by the blog-police is not endorsed anywhere in those links.
If you repeatedly find yourself assaulted by popups then perhaps you should actually look at the link before you click it. I find it highly annoying to select a topic based on the title, and find the discussion of that topic diluted by self-righteous pimp-police spamming rude remarks.
If you REALLY wanted to discourage blog-pimping, the simple answer would be to let people post the entire content in response to a blog-pimp post. That would remove any incentive to click the link, not ruin the FR conversation and result in a far less confrontational atmosphere here at FR.
No impediment exists to anyone posting the entirety of their own content.
Yes - it's very annoying reading the snarks from the Usual Suspects. I like your solution.
Not sure the Usual Suspects are capable of doing a simple cut-n-paste, though. It's more fun to troll, I guess...