I didn’t vote for Dole either. I voted for W the first time. In 2004 I just wasn’t motivated after the Patriot Act.
I voted for Nixon and Ford. Ford is a another regret. I voted for Reagan twice. And like you, that’s the only votes I’d do again.
I always vote, and always for the one who doesn't have a D after his name who stands the best chance of winning.
Voting is a purely political act. It is not a statement of principle.