Back in 2007 Bush, McCain, Tony Snowe all used those same argument as Ryan/Rubio are now, that paying a fine (back taxes???) and some probation period magically made a Green card and citizenship into something other than amnesty.
But clearly if they get to still stay here and get citizenship or even a green card that is a jump ahead.
Those waiting in other countries the legal way will be losing out to them. they wont be getting EITC and instate tuition discounts and minority Affirm Action status and on., while outside the country.
Now it is true that family members get a jump ahead too under the current system. That is a flaw.
Bottom line is our gub’mint refuses to enforce current immigration laws now and sure as hell won’t enforce any amnesty laws later.