Agreed. And some rather surprisings things are very possible.
This could very well be one of those things.
Again, just because you can't see how this can be done, doesn't mean it won't work.
m = mass at velocity
m0 = rest mass
V = velocity of interest
c = speed of light
As an object is accelerated it acquires mass in accordance with the formula above. As V2 approaches c2 the ratio of the two approaches 1 and the square root of 1 minus the ratio approaches zero and the mass at velocity approaches infinity.
If somehow you were able to exceed the speed of light with a real rest mass you end up dividing by an imaginary number (the square root of -1, or i ) and you end up with an apparent mass with an imaginary component.
An interesting thought experiment is to start with an imaginary rest mass. This requires that the velocity always be greater than c to yield a real apparent mass. And no, I have know idea what it means for mass to have an imaginary component.
But there it is.
Check out Relativistic velocity transformation as a genitor of transformation equations for the gory details of the math.