How so? The only scenario I can see that happening is if one of the parents is a dual citizen.
If dual citizenship at birth is a disqualification for being a natural born citizen - then Happerestt (sic) would be incorrect
Happerset never ruled on the other circumstances, it just stated that there were doubts, so how could it be incorrect?
So now the criteria is born of two American citizens with no other citizenship and born on American soil?
England thought that Americans were English until 1815. Between the adoption of the Constitution in 1787 and the end of the war of 1812 - in 1815 - Presidents Fillmore, Pierce, Buchanan, Lincoln and Johnson were all born.
Were none of these U.S. Presidents qualified because England considered them English according to English law?