Why can’t I marry my brother and/or sister, and not consumate the marriage” We could save money on taxes.
Why not a man and a goat?
Ask these questions of any pro-gay marriage supporter, and you'll find out that they indeed have a line, just as you do. They just disagree where the line should be drawn.
All the arguments for gay marriage are emotional pablum, and of course they can apply to all kinds of unusual relationships.
Why can’t we have polygamy? If we have say, a guy and 2 girls, the gay rights movement should be happy because the women can be bisexual and everyone can have one big party.
And won’t a child be so lucky to have a father and two mothers?
Once you let the left bitch slap you with their arguments, we are through the looking glass. That’s why you needed to stand up to them at the beginning.
No, it will not be good if we allow gays to marry and adopt so a kid is raised knowing he has two “fathers” who put their penises in each other’s rectums. It’s just absurd. But hey, they “love” each other. Ok, good for them enjoy it but leave society alone.
If you don’t consummate, it’s not a marriage.
Remember the heat that Scalia got when he said the decision to rule the Texas Law against Sodomy Law as Unconstitutional would be a slippery slope?
You are right (under the argument made by the left). Who says love has to be romantic/physical love? How about platonic love? Brotherly love? Since marriage is no longer about procreation and family, all bets are off.