Indeed. But the issue that the dissent raises, which is a valid one, is that the textbooks were not lawfully made under the Copyright Act. And they were not lawfully made under the Copyright Act because the Copyright Act does not apply in foreign countries. How can a work be lawfully made under the Copyright Act when it is not subject to the Copyright Act?
Exactly and that’s why there can not be enforcement of copyright laws with items being brought here to be resold because there’s no way to tell if something is lawfully made from a different country.