[Catsrus]

I don’t see anything to indicate he’s an American.

[GVnana]

He is from Argentina.

[Shadow44]

They meant as in from the Americas viz. Western Hemisphere.

[nascarnation]

Argentina where he was born is in South America.

so he’s definitely an American in the conventional definition.

although his father was an Italian immigrant.

[terycarl]

I don’t see anything to indicate he’s an American

hee's from Argentina....Argentina is in south america.....ie:American

[afraidfortherepublic]

Of course he’s an American — a South American, born in Argentina.

[HangnJudge]

I don’t see anything to indicate he’s an American.

South American