So US soil is what makes you American?
Jose and Guadeloupe can run the border, squirt out a kid and they have rights but mine does not?
No it does not, but law does. You know full well things have changed over the centuries ad there are abundant case law and regulations that define citizenship.
The law that was in affect when Obama was born would definitely rule him out as NBC, probably even Citizen, but depending on what actions he took in later years he could indeed be a naturalized citizen.
Idiots within the Justice department and Idiots in Congress have muddied the waters considerably.
The little dance that the Senate pulled off to Deem McCain eligible was just that, a little dance, it was deigned to bring Obama into the fold, without question.
When Freepers begin to argue irrelevant case law and ignore common sense then the Republic is lost and those of us in the older population should just be thankful we will not live to see the worst of what is to come, and it will come.