Posted on 02/14/2013 4:33:20 PM PST by SMGFan
Couldn't they have evacuated the 4,000 people earlier? Too costly? Not necessary?
4,000 people? You’d probably need 5 or 6 good-sized ships. And no guarantee the conditions on those won’t become as bad.
I’d bet that evacuation at sea would be quite dangerous and by the time it would take to set up a process to do it safely, they could be in port and off loaded.
I say we start a petition to send the First Family on a Carnival Cruise.
They would have gotten better treatment if they had sunk like the Titanic. I assume there would be enough lifeboats for everyone and therefoe they could use them to transfer to other rescue ships. Or do a transfer of passengers at sea.
I can’t imagine anything that could wrong when evacuating 4000 geriatrics and drunk slops from one ship to another in 10 foot seas.
these things should come with oars, imagine 3,400 passengers and 1,000 crew members rowing.....
“Row, Row, Row your boat...”
These passengers are going to have a great story to tell, they are going to get a refund, they will almost certainly get a free cruise voucher and who knows what other freebies from Carnival, many will be on TV, some will write books, a few will find a way to get a realityTV gig out of it, etc. I just don’t buy that this is all that harrowing. The people are completely safe, the boat isn’t going to capsize. It’s a big adventure!
I understand that although ICKY , this isn’t an emergency ,, as to why the slow response ,, I believe the ship is Bahamian flagged , call Nassau and complain to someone there.. not a USA problem. At least they didn’t run this one aground and kill people... although I fail to see how they couldn’t make temporary repairs and get SOME of the engines running...
I can’t even imagine what a place like that becomes as a disease-plagued, sewage-laden, crime-riddled SHTF hellhole becomes, when everything goes wrong. The SuperDome in NOLA during Katrina quickly comes to mind. No one’s fully-prepared for the desperation which quickly comes, and a rescue seems to take forever.
Reason #1 why I’ve never gone on one.
You’re too realistic.
That doesn’t fit in with the MSM hype.
CNN seems to think this is because the ship employs foreign nationals.
Could you imagine the costs/quality of cruises if they were manned by unionized US employees?
I found a FREE set of tickets for a Carnival Caribbean Cruise in the mail last night LOL
I dropped them in the trash.
Bon voyage “Poop Sloop”!!! LOL
Good idea for a tv show. Call it Survivor. (nevermind)
My wife asked the same question and I reminded her. We have been on quite a few cruise ships. I said look at the people. Now Carnival generally has a younger population but I would imagine that 20% of the guests use canes, walkers, and electric chairs. How do they get these people off the ship and onto another one. That would be extremely difficult to handle, even into the lifeboats and then to the other ship. Of course they do not need ladders to get on the other ship but they still have to dock at the tendering door(s) and in the open sea that can be rough.
Without power it’s bound to be really nasty ,, toilets (vacuum operated) don’t flush , no air movement (portholes generally don’t open) , no power to cook whatever food didn’t spoil (most food is fresh/refrigerated loaded at departure time) ,, even for juice/water there is no power to desalinate and make water or operate any of the cafeteria equipment ...
The Carpathia picked up 700-plus Titanic survivors from their lifeboats in a matter of hours. Four or five hours, and those boats were scattered over a big stretch of water. After the fact, the Captain was given the option of doing a transfer at sea to a larger ship and he declined, saying it would be too traumatic for the survivors. But it would have been possible.
Not a fun cruise. Worse than being in Hudson County w/o power for a week after Sandy.
No one’s fully-prepared for the desperation which quickly comes
************************************************
I’d commandeer some rum from one of the duty free shops , tell them to charge my room and relax ,, not much else to do...
I heard they were reduced to making onion sandwiches.
No liverwurst no mustard, Nothin!
Seems like these people would understand that we now have airplanes that will take them from point A to point B and without having to tromp through raw sewage and get you to your destination in a couple of hours.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.