[airedale]

Doesn’t that mean that all the rules and decisions they have made since their appointment are void?

[green iguana]

I’m no lawyer, but since they vacated the Board’s ruling in this case, it certainly seems that way.

[Cboldt]

-- Doesn't that mean that all the rules and decisions they have made since their appointment are void? --

It does, but I don't know (for sure) what steps or how other parties will obtain relief. I assume they have to sue for a judgment, just like Canning did.

Also of interest, there are many Article III judges whose appointments are unconstitutional, too. It's a fairly big can of worms.