I read the entire NYT story and it is little more than a swipe on the ‘poor rubes’ in Appalachia. Why can't they be as high class as the deviants in the Big Apple? However, it uncovers little to no real evidence. Neither does Anonymous. Rumor & Innuendo are not proof.
To me it sounds like there was most certainly shenanigans going on, but even with the State Prosecutor involved, it is going to be a very difficult to get a conviction. No physical evidence of ANY kind. No toxicology, No reliable Eye witnesses. Real tough case.
Here is an interesting article: http://hsconnect.com/page/content.detail/id/578936/Teen-rape-case-moves-forward.html