Obviously no prophecy scholar is infallible, and I may differ with all of them on certain certain things.
The point remains that Reagan’s critique of the Muslim Antichrist theory is a very good one. I also posted a link quoting others such as Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum and Dr. Mark Hitchcock who give reasons why they too reject the Muslim Antichrist theory.
Here again are the links, for anyone interested to read point-by-point critiques of the Muslim Antichrist theory:
An Evaluation of the Muslim Antichrist Theory
by Dr. David R. Reagan
http://www.pre-trib.org/data/pdf/Reagan-AnEvaluationoftheMus.pdf
Will the Antichrist be a Muslim? No.
(This article quotes Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum and Dr. Mark Hitchcock.)
http://www.lamblion.com/files/publications/blog/blog_Will-The-Antichrist-Be-A-Muslim-No.pdf
Here is an early response by Richardson:
http://archives.joelstrumpet.com/?p=1690
A Response to Dr. David Reagan By Joel Richardson
January 11, 2009 in Updates