Even before then. There were a bunch of Republicans scared of Reagan as well, and he clearly proved them wrong.
I believe that almost all of us here on FR are conservatives, and agree on underlying values. Where we disagree is on strategy.
The truth is that a majority of the American people do not agree with us across the board on all those issues. Nor do they agree with the left. The left is winning this war for the future of our country via relentless incrementalism, holding ground when they are in the minority, and then pushing for change when they manage to get a majority. Tactical retreats, strategic advances. It's ugly, but it has worked for them. It also helps that they are not above lying to voters to accompish what they want.
How to best combat and reverse that trend is a matter of strategy, not principle. I think grass roots supporters sticking to their guns is important, but at the same time, I don't think a "no retreat" rule works any better in politics than it did for Hitler in late 42 through the end of the war. There are small issues that matter little, but that can be demagogued very successfully and cost elections. And on those issues, I'd rather see a conservative candidate take a tactical loss if necessary for a larger victory.
I think it is unfortunate that a difference in strategy has divided so many here who actually agree on principle. I don't trust Romney, though I do like his selection on Ryan even though I disagree with him on gay issues. I just view Romney as the political equivalent of a strategic retreat from Stalingrad, rather than telling the Sixth Army to die in place at the hands of the marxist(s). I don't think electing Romney is going to mean victory for the conservative agenda, but I do think he may stop a more complete victory for the left.
I'll be happy when this election is over so that we all can remind ourselves that we're actually on the same side.
To be totally honest, I am not sure how or if I will vote fot the top of the ticket. I am not, nor have I been a Republican since 1998. Now that doesn't mean I haven't voted for Republican candidates. I loath John McCain and still can't get the stink off me from voting for him 4 years ago.
So, again, thanks for your reasoned post to me. God Bless you and yours and May God Bless America.