That's exactly what Brown Deer is doing, stating this bogus theory as fact with no credible supporting data. None, zip, nada.
The scenario is entirely supported by the known data. It is the equation the fits the curve of data points.
Obama returned to the US in 1971. Even though his legal guardians were staying in Indonesia. Sorry, you can not just drop off a kid in a country were his legal guardians ARE NOT RESIDENTS. So how does he re-establish valid guardianship and citizenship after being a 100% Indonesian citizen?
When you have data points that explain that then rocks can be thrown at this scenario. But without an acceptable alternative this is the 'ruling on the field'.
If the 'the booth' wants to change it present the evidence.