[Williams]

Scalia also said it is not a tax, in the dissent. Do we disagree with Scalia and agree with Roberts on this?

However, yes, Romney should consider firing this guy for stupid comments.

[patriotspride]

“Scalia also said it is not a tax, in the dissent”

---

Thanks for that clarification.

To me Scalia/Romney are saying it should not have been passed on either the commerce clause, or some interpretation of Tax aka Roberts Opinion.

In that regard calling it a penalty appears to be the correct interpretation.
Hence Romneys, Bad Law, Bad Policy comments.