Hardly.
Both religions require the death and/or enslavement of infidels.
Both religions are spread by war and violence
Both religions require absolutely loyalty
Both religions prohibited by death and criticism or questioning of their religions
Shall I go on?
And please google the word - Taqiyya - yes, it is OK to lie to an infidel.
Modern times now, not 1000 years ago. These 2 religions are far from equal.