Replies

now find an authority that states NBC in our Constitution stems from Vattel,

I've already shown it in post #81. George Tucker's annotated version of Blackstone's Commentaries was literally THE book for early American law, and his View of the Constitution which comes FROM that work was accepted as legal evidence by the US Supreme Court in the defense of the RKBA case District of Columbia vs. Heller.

Tucker specifically mentions Vattel.

[BTW – your link to a blog was a joke]

-----

AH! I recognize the tactic now.

You post like someone looking for an answer when all you really want is a response.

When that response comes [and particularly when that response is not in TOTAL agreement with yours] you offer no true rebuttal. You either jump up & down point and scream – HA HA!, like its some kind of proof or ask a question that's already been answered.

Then you repeat the cycle over and over again.

-----

You, sir are what I call a 'mental masturbater'.

And I have NO desire to hold whatever needs holding while you do it.

I’ve already shown it in post #81.

You’ve shown nothing relating to this thread. (And I see you are reverting to ridicule).

Let’s take a look at what you referenced in Post 83. Your first reference, referring to The Law Of Nations has nothing to do with Vattel. It is a reference to Blackstone’s Commentaries on the Laws of England, Book 4, Chapter 5 entitled Of Offenses Against the Laws of Nations. (http://www.lonang.com/exlibris/blackstone/bla-405.htm). Interesting mistake on your part!

Your Tucker reference which mentions Vattel speaks not a word about NBC but some other topic not related to this thread.

What are you proving? Certainly nothing to support your contention that NBC has anything to do with Vattel’s interpretation.

I’ve already shown it in post #81. George Tucker’s annotated version of Blackstone’s Commentaries was literally THE book for early American law, and his View of the Constitution which comes FROM that work was accepted as legal evidence by the US Supreme Court in the defense of the RKBA case District of Columbia vs. Heller.

If you had read your own reference you would see you are proving my point. Blackstone had a greater influence with our framers than anyone else.

You, sir are what I call a ‘mental masturbater’.

And I have NO desire to hold whatever needs holding while you do it.

Nice talk! I see you’ve left the thread. If you want to play in the bigs mama, you need the right bat.

By you quoting (with great fanfare by the way) Blackstone as THE authority with our framers, you sent yourself back to the T-ball league. Nice chatting with you while it lasted, hope you learned something from the practice.