I am not a birther... never followed it any more than reading here on FR. Here is a bit of perspective from me. It does not matter what you or any other lawyer says... it no longer matters what our Constitution says... the Law is so corrupt and infected today that the US Constitution and case law says whatever any activist judge says it says and we have a SCOTUS that is so afraid of any case dealing with politics that they are basically castrated as an effective protection of our basic Constitutional rights. That my friend is a fact... so the law is whatever holder and a black robed terrorist says that it is. That is a thoroughly healthy and realistic view of our current situation. I agree. The "law" nowadays means what the judges SAY it means. I disagree that it is the ACTUAL law, but it is what is enforced and called "law."