You need to read my post a bit closer.
I wasmore or less responding to the idea of living in cities when TSHTF but also that living close enough for easy travel from cities is IMHO not a safe idea, generally speaking of course. Travis McGee has posted a cube of relative locations and I agree with him. Another point about jobs is in a fairly severe SHTF situation there won’t be jobs very much. It’s already more and more in that territory. Again IMHO people who can seriously reduce spending and find some ways of garnering income without having to live in close proximity to large numbers of people would be wise to do so.