[El Sordo]

Do some authorities go further and include as citizens children born within the jurisdiction without reference to the citizenship of their parents?

As to this class have there been doubts?

For the purposes of that case was it necessary to solve these doubts?

[edge919]

Unlike you, I'm not going to dodge the questions you ask. In return, you need to answer mine. Which class did the Minor court characterize as natural-born citizens?? (Hint: It was only ONE of the two classes it mentioned.)

Do some authorities go further and include as citizens children born within the jurisdiction without reference to the citizenship of their parents?

Yes. Are these natural-born citizens? No, because they are only natural-born when the parents are citizens.

As to this class have there been doubts?

100 percent yes. If the parents were citizens, there would be no doubts. When the parents are NOT citizens, then the doubts must be resolved through non-natural means, such as statutory law or Constitutional amendment.

For the purposes of that case was it necessary to solve these doubts?

Absolutely not. Virginia Minor fit the courts definition of citizenship with no doubt ... the ONLY one that was characterized as "natural-born citizens."

Are you starting to understand yet?? These questions do NOT help your defiant position.