[chrisnj]

‘but the principles were and the formula was either/or.’
that is what the modern pundits want you to believe. Supreme court cases, founding father’s correspondence and “Law of Nations’ all point to Jus Sanguinis AND Jus Soli.

That is why Congress should clarify this, but we all know they are too chicken to do so.

[jimfree]

Supreme court cases, founding father’s correspondence and “Law of Nations’ all point to Jus Sanguinis AND Jus Soli

Maybe, but that's not how they are ruling.