[j_tull]

Exactly! Why were they dispatched if it’s so expensive to answer a call? Do they arrive and rollout “Don’t let this happen to you!” banners for the neighbors to see? Why is fire protection not part of the property tax? Foul setup, that.

[Doe Eyes]

Why is fire protection not part of the property tax? Foul setup, that.

Perhaps the citizens refuse to allow the local government to force them to pay taxes for a service they don't want to pay for?

Would you prevent citizens that option?

[j_tull]

Sorry Doe, my internet connection pooped in mid reply..

Would you prevent citizens that option?

That is a fair question. Ala carte city services? If you are having a heart attack and haven't paid the "ambulance" surtax, would they stand there and watch you die? I was thinking more along the lines of the city extorting additional cash from the residents by withholding an essential service that should be a function of local government and funded by the existing taxes. I would (admittedly) hesitate to allow an opt-out though it does seem to run contrary to the principal of individual liberty, doesn't it. Interesting question, I'll have to think about it.

[j_tull]

So, I saved my reply in at text file which I pasted and posted when I got back on the internet, 12 hours after the fact. Then, I read post 130 which explains the facts of the case a little better. I will now reluctantly agree the firefighters acted as their policy requires (still can't say it's the right thing). Your original question from a philosophy/practicality standpoint, remains a good one.