Well there would be the flat tax also. Your right a single male (no fams allowed) would probably not have to pay the Income tax, but they would be VERY easy to TRACK if they didn’t leave at the end of their time.
However for ANY of this to work the border has to be secure and the illegals “encourage” to leave. I would support a Law that made hiring an illegal a felony with forfeiture of business, jail time and fine. Maybe THAT would get the attention of these people that encourage the breaking of Federal immigration Law.
I believe that the only way to get a handle on the problem will be a bit draconian simply because we have allowed the problem of illegals to get so large.
First, secure the border, then;
No bennies or medical care of any sort. No schooling, no housing, no welfare, no work, no driver’s licenses or state ID cards, no anchor baby nonsense, no marrying a legal resident or citizen, nothing, nada, zip, zilch, zero.
If a bracero type program were implemented, I would not favor them paying SS or income tax because then they’d be back sucking on the public teat. They’d get all of their income tax back and then some, anyway.
I’m with you on hammering any business that hires illegals. We would need some sort of E-verify system though to protect the employers.