[Semper911]

I made a mistake and in my reply (the one you have failed to grasp) I restated what I meant.

But forget all that. Give me your definition of Natural Born Citizen. Then I’ll know if we have something to argue about.

[allmendream]

U.S. law should always be a reflection of our best understanding of natural law.

If someone is born a citizen under U.S. law, in recognition of the natural allegiance they have due to conditions of birth, they are a natural born citizen.

Of U.S. citizens, one is either a natural born citizen or one must be “naturalized” into that state of allegiance.

There is no third category.

Like most things people make up, they cannot seem to agree - that is why birthers tend to be all over the map as far as what this third category is.