Replies

Shall we trade facts, then?

Is it a fact that the Pons-Fleishmann effect has been replicated more than 14,700 times?

Is it a fact that you have not contributed one line to the effort to determine whether Rossi’s results are real or faked?
How to Prove that the Rossi/Focardi eCAT LENR is Real (or fake)
LENR.QUMBO.com ^ | April 6, 2011 | Alan Fletcher
Posted on Sunday, June 05, 2011 7:52:15 PM by Kevmo
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/2730401/posts

Is it a fact that you acknowledge coming onto these threads for entertainment, like a typical entertainment troll?

Is it a fact that the Journal of Nuclear Physics was started after Rossi was told that his results were impossible?

Is it a fact that the kettle of water that Rossi supposedly heated up was boiling AFTER the INPUT POWER was turned OFF? (Heat after death)

Is it a fact that the last demo Rossi allowed the device to be weighed, and dismantled to check for hidden wires, tubes or batteries?

Is it a fact that the Pons-Fleishmann effect has been replicated more than 14,700 times?

What is the Pons-Fleishmann effect and does it include measurement error?

Is it a fact that you have not contributed one line to the effort to determine whether Rossi’s results are real or faked?

I don't have access to the device and Rossi keeps access tightly controlled. I have no way to verify the access that others have had, or whether they are being honest. I approach this as an investor would approach this, and Rossi stinks of fraud.

Is it a fact that you acknowledge coming onto these threads for entertainment, like a typical entertainment troll?

I come on these threads to prevent you from promoting fraud. I do get some entertainment out of it. It's the only way I can put up with your childish behavior.

Is it a fact that the Journal of Nuclear Physics was started after Rossi was told that his results were impossible?

No matter what, it's still a fraudulent representation.

Is it a fact that the kettle of water that Rossi supposedly heated up was boiling AFTER the INPUT POWER was turned OFF? (Heat after death)

We have no way to verify what's going on. It is admitted that it takes a hot plate many hours to heat up the ecat before the water is boiled, whereas a hot plate alone can do the job in minutes.

Is it a fact that the last demo Rossi allowed the device to be weighed, and dismantled to check for hidden wires, tubes or batteries?

I wasn't there. I have no way to verify what was done or wasn't done in an honest manner.

I have a question for you. A serious one so don't flame me. As I understand it electricity is applied to nickel and it changes to copper thereby creating large amount of heat. Is that the basic idea behind E-cat? That however is not the question. Where does the electricity that starts the catalyst come from and how much is needed? Will there be a need for a coal(or nuke)powered generator in order to keep this thing going or is the reaction self sustaining once it gets started? Sorry for all the basic question but I am not a physicist and I am a long time out of school.