Say that to the Serbs in Krajina, Christians in Afghanistan and jews in Iraq and Morocco...
Expulsions happen. All that is needed is will and power.
Leave the arabs in place and it will come back to haunt the Israelis in the future. Win the war and the local muslims will go back to biding their time and doing their best to outbreed the jews. And for every decade that passes Israel will be in greater peril.
So what if the muslims are angry? What will they do? Start a campaign of terror and be determined to wipe out Israel once they have the strength?
Expulsion happens, true. But it will not happen that way here. Aside from the fact that we Jooos! are a bunch of soft-hearted fools, we’ve never actually done any wholesale expulsions. It was unnecessary, because in 1948, the Arabs all ran after hearing the false, exaggerated rumors circulating about what happened in Deir Yassin. It would have happened in 1967, but Moshe Dayan stupidly opened his mouth and said that the Jews have no claim to Yesha, and promised to give it all back. The Arabs looking to flee from the wicked Jooos! then unpacked their bags and stayed. A similar thing will happen should we have to fight and conclusively win another major war, only this time Moshe Dayan won’t be around to make stupid statements.
It’s not a desirable result here, because unfortunately there are many Jews mixed in with the Arab population. These are called “tinukot shenishbu” in Jewish law. Their mothers were rebellious teenagers/leftist idiots/abductees who ended up forcibly married to Arabs. Their children must not be abandoned by the Jewish community, as they would be if there were an expulsion. There are also entire tribes of Bedouins who have for centuries been practicing Jewish rites in secret, who are descendants of Jews forced to convert to Islam. Similar communities have come out in the open in recent years in Portugal and Spain, now that the Inquisition is gone. I’ll take my chances with the Arabs we have with us for the sake of those of my people trapped among them, and the hopes of freeing them.
It’s also a fact that the Arab construction workers get the job done. I know from my own observations, and what the Jewish contractor who hires them tells me. Jewish crews have chronic absenteeisms. Consequently, for various anthropological reasons, the Arabs dominate construction here.
I would favor paying Arabs wishing to emigrate a “sal pleita” or emigrant package commensurate with what Jews are paid as “sal klita” or immigration packages. They could use that package to resettle elsewhere.
But mass expulsions will not and should not happen, both for the reasons enumerated above, and because it’s something that Muslims do to non-Muslims which marks them as barbarians, as per all of your examples.
Incidentally, the Jews of Morrocco voluntarily emigrated. They were not expelled, but wanted an existence as something other than dhimmes. This I’ve heard from Moroccans who made the move to Israel.
Expulsion happens, true. But it will not happen that way here. Aside from the fact that we Jooos! are a bunch of soft-hearted fools, we’ve never actually done any wholesale expulsions. It was unnecessary, because in 1948, the Arabs all ran after hearing the false, exaggerated rumors circulating about what happened in Deir Yassin. It would have happened in 1967, but Moshe Dayan stupidly opened his mouth and said that the Jews have no claim to Yesha, and promised to give it all back. The Arabs looking to flee from the wicked Jooos! then unpacked their bags and stayed. A similar thing will happen should we have to fight and conclusively win another major war, only this time Moshe Dayan won’t be around to make stupid statements.
It’s not a desirable result here, because unfortunately there are many Jews mixed in with the Arab population. These are called “tinukot shenishbu” in Jewish law. Their mothers were rebellious teenagers/leftist idiots/abductees who ended up forcibly married to Arabs. Their children must not be abandoned by the Jewish community, as they would be if there were an expulsion. There are also entire tribes of Bedouins who have for centuries been practicing Jewish rites in secret, who are descendants of Jews forced to convert to Islam. Similar communities have come out in the open in recent years in Portugal and Spain, now that the Inquisition is gone. I’ll take my chances with the Arabs we have with us for the sake of those of my people trapped among them, and the hopes of freeing them.
It’s also a fact that the Arab construction workers get the job done. I know from my own observations, and what the Jewish contractor who hires them tells me. Jewish crews have chronic absenteeisms. Consequently, for various anthropological reasons, the Arabs dominate construction here.
I would favor paying Arabs wishing to emigrate a “sal pleita” or emigrant package commensurate with what Jews are paid as “sal klita” or immigration packages. They could use that package to resettle elsewhere.
But mass expulsions will not and should not happen, both for the reasons enumerated above, and because it’s something that Muslims do to non-Muslims which marks them as barbarians, as per all of your examples.
Incidentally, the Jews of Morrocco voluntarily emigrated. They were not expelled, but wanted an existence as something other than dhimmes. This I’ve heard from Moroccans who made the move to Israel.