See my post 18. In addition to the Carter appointee, the other judges in the cases were appointed by Presidents Reagan, Eisenhower, and Nixon.
When you are pulling apples out of a spoiled barrel, the odds are that you will get a bad one much of the time. Roe v Wade, Kelo, and numerous and sundry lesser decisions by the Supreme and lesser courts proves that the legal system is way out of whack. That is pretty much a standard conservative position nowadays. Do you disagree?
In any case, it is not evidence as to what Article II meant, it is only evidence that a lot of people don't know what the h3ll they are talking about.