You won't get any argument from me about Foxman's ADL. They are unquestionably more circumspect about antisemitism on the right than antisemitism on the left, even though the latter is by far the larger problem in the US and the western world today.
It's a bit of a problem to call this an "outrageous antisemitic insult" in and of itself. But if you factor in Obama's considerable history, you would have to say that the Freudian slip is consistent with his anti-Jewish inclinations.
BTW, Foxman's office is located in New York (a stone's throw from the UN), not in California.
You can bet that's the least it would be called if it were a republican or a tea party member. That was my point.
Mark