[Repeal 16-17]

Now I understand from where you are coming. You aren't objecting to Cain's plan per se; your problem with it is that you don't trust the federal government. I appreciate that, but then how do you reform the tax code without overthrowing the federal government?

[andyk]

You aren't objecting to Cain's plan per se; your problem with it is that you don't trust the federal government. I appreciate that, but then how do you reform the tax code without overthrowing the federal government?

Ah yes, that is essentially correct. If someone could somehow guarantee that the 9-9-9 would only move in the direction of personal liberty, then it sounds like a great plan. Sadly, it will not happen. We have 200 years of history as our guide.

I don't think it's possible to fully reform the tax code and restore a federalist system without repealing the 16th and 17th amendments.